| 1 | Daughters of St. Paul Choir | "Angels We Have Heard on High" |
| 2 | Sonora Carruseles | "Micaela" |
| 3 | Sidney James | "Three Kings" |
| 4 | Sidney James | "Joy to the World" |
| 5 | Adrian Painter | "Deck the Halls" |
| 6 | The Cary Brothers | "Something" |
| 7 | Gina Rene | "The First Noel" |
| 8 | Arthur Holden | "Greensleeves" |
| 9 | Arthur Holden | "Silent Night" |
| 10 | Adam Pascal | "Winter Light" |